Client Alerts & Newsletters

New York Court of Appeals Issues Decision on Bellefonte Issue

December 14, 2017

The New York Court of Appeals issued a decision today on what is commonly referred to as the Bellefonte issue. A copy of the decision can be found here.

In Global Reinsurance Corp. of Am. v. Century Indemnity Co., the Court ruled, on certification from the Second Circuit, that “[u]nder New York law generally,” and in particular its prior decision, Excess Ins. Co. v. Factory Mut. Ins. Co., 3 N.Y.3d 577 (2004), “there is neither a rule of construction nor a presumption that a per occurrence liability limitation in a reinsurance contract caps all obligations of the reinsurer, such as payments made to reimburse the reinsured’s defense costs.” 

This decision has significant implications for facultative certificates subject to New York law. In the decades since the Second Circuit’s decision in Bellefonte Reins. Co. v. Aetna Cas.& Sur. Co., 903 F.2d 910 (2d Cir 1990), numerous courts (both inside and outside of New York) have relied upon Bellefonte for the proposition that the dollar amount stated in the “Reinsurance Accepted” provision of the parties’ facultative certificate unambiguously capped the reinsurer’s liability for both loss and expense. Today’s decision from the New York Court of Appeals makes clear that, under New York law, a court cannot “disregard the precise terminology that the parties used and simply assume … that any clause bearing the generic marker of a ‘limitation of liability’ or ‘reinsurance accepted’ clause was intended to be cost-inclusive.” Rather, courts must interpret facultative certificates by “look[ing] to the language of the [certificate] above all else,” keeping in mind “that even modest variations on the face of a written agreement can alter the meaning of a critical term.” (Citations and internal quotations omitted.)

For more information, please contact the professional(s) listed below, or your regular Crowell & Moring contact.

Harry P. Cohen
Partner – New York
Phone: +1.212.803.4044

Michael K. Robles
Partner – New York
Phone: +1.212.803.4035

Brian J. O'Sullivan
Senior Counsel – New York
Phone: +1.212.803.4056

Kelly H. Tsai
Senior Counsel – New York
Phone: +1.212.803.4069

Crowell & Moring LLP is an international law firm with offices in the United States, Europe, MENA, and Asia that represents clients in litigation and arbitration, regulatory and policy, and transactional and corporate matters. The firm is internationally recognized for its representation of Fortune 500 companies in high-stakes litigation and government-facing matters, as well as its ongoing commitment to pro bono service and diversity, equity, and inclusion.

View Desktop Site | Mobile Sitemap |

Contact | Subscribe | Terms of Use | Privacy Statement | Alumni

© Crowell & Moring LLP 2023
Attorney advertising - prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.